
Donald Trump wants a Democratic Senate nominee prosecuted, removed from the ballot and possibly denied her seat over a spoiler candidate. Yet his party has spent this cycle propping up its own spoilers, weaponizing a survivor’s childhood abuse, redrawing maps on command and riding a record wave of billionaire money. On the eve of a record-turnout election, the outrage tells you less about Alaska than about what Trump plans to do if he loses.
Start with what is true, because the truth is the one thing the President of the United States has no use for this week. In Alaska’s toss-up Senate race, there are two men named Dan Sullivan on the ballot: the Republican incumbent and a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg. On October 28, The New York Times reported that operatives tied to Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign and national Democrats worked to recruit spoiler candidates, including the Petersburg Sullivan, to draw votes away from the incumbent. Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee deny it.
This board will not pretend that is acceptable. Recruiting a name-alike to confuse voters is a cheap trick no matter which party does it, and Notre Dame election-law professor Derek Muller was right to call it a dirty one, as PBS NewsHour reported. If investigators find laws were broken, the people responsible should answer for it. But a dirty trick is not a stolen election, and what Donald Trump and his Justice Department have done in response is something far more dangerous than the trick itself.
I. What Actually Happened in Alaska
The Petersburg candidate’s presence on the ballot was litigated for months. A top state elections official initially ruled him ineligible, finding his filing was meant to confuse or mislead, but Alaska’s courts reinstated him and the state Supreme Court let his candidacy stand. That is the system working: a dispute raised, heard and decided by the courts under state law.
Alaska’s ranked-choice ballot also blunts the confusion Republicans claim to fear. As Alaska Public Media explained, a voter who ranks both Sullivans still has the vote count toward whichever of them is stronger. Even so, the President chose escalation at every turn:
Sources for the timeline: the Alaska Beacon on Fair Deal Alaska’s funding; PBS NewsHour on the lawsuit and prosecution demand; The New Republic on Dunleavy and Trump’s comments; and NBC News on the dismissal.
“It’s hard to believe that she can even be allowed to run.”
— President Donald Trump, on Mary Peltola, via The New Republic
Peltola, for her part, has tried to drag the race back to what voters actually care about. “Nobody’s waking up worried about ballot composition,” she told voters in Soldotna, insisting her focus is bills, affordability and health care. Even Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski, who endorsed Sullivan, condemned ballot stacking. Fair enough. The question is why the President’s outrage runs in only one direction.
II. The Hypocrisy Ledger
Ballot stacking is not a Democratic invention. In Alaska alone this year, super PACs spent more than $2 million trying to elevate political unknowns onto the general-election ballot, and the money came from both sides. But the Republican version of the playbook has a long paper trail, and none of it moved the President to demand prosecutions.
Alaska Senate · 2026
Fair Deal Alaska boosted a Green Party candidate and a fringe Democrat in the August primary. FEC filings later showed $650,000 came from the Senate Leadership Fund, the GOP’s flagship Senate super PAC, which has drawn much of its recent cash from Elon Musk. Alaska Beacon
Alaska House · 2024–26
Eric Hafner, a Democrat serving a federal prison sentence and who has never lived in Alaska, made the 2024 ballot. Democrats sued to remove him; the Alaska Republican Party fought to keep him on, and a national GOP group ran ads boosting him. He is on the ballot again this year. Alaska Beacon
Ohio Senate · 2026
A super PAC with ties to Republican vendors, Enough Promises Ohio, has spent roughly $1.8 million promoting socialist Greg Levy and attacking Democrat Sherrod Brown in the race against Sen. Jon Husted. NBC4 Columbus
Ohio Governor · 2026
Vivek Ramaswamy’s campaign ran an ad featuring Democrat Amy Acton’s estranged mother calling her daughter a liar about a childhood in which records show she was removed from the home after her stepfather was charged with raping her. FactCheck.org
Texas Senate · 2026
Vice President JD Vance made a joke implying Democratic nominee James Talarico is gay, feeding a long innuendo campaign, while MAGA voices pushed a since-debunked claim that Talarico had been in a mental hospital. CNN
North Carolina · 2026
A GOP congressional candidate and the national party teamed up on an ad that appears to use AI to depict her opponent dancing with drag queens. CNN
Honest readers should note that Democratic-aligned groups have also played spoiler games, including in Alaska. That is precisely the point. A president who cared about clean elections would ask Congress and the states to close these loopholes for everyone. Instead, Trump has weaponized one side’s misconduct to threaten a certification he does not control, while his own party’s super PAC bankrolled the same tactic in the same race.
III. The Lowest Blow: A Survivor’s Childhood as Attack Ad
Of all this cycle’s tactics, none was crueler than the Ohio ad. Dr. Amy Acton, the physician who led Ohio’s Department of Health, has spoken openly for years about surviving abuse and homelessness. Ramaswamy’s campaign put her estranged mother, Donna Arthur, on camera to call Acton a liar. FactCheck.org reviewed the record and found it supports Acton’s account: she was removed from her mother’s custody at 12 after her stepfather was charged with raping her. Acton’s brother has said their mother remained married to that man until he died.
“Who wouldn’t use such an ad? I would, it’s called, ‘hitting pay dirt.’”
— President Donald Trump, Straight Arrow News
The backlash came from inside the GOP. According to CNN, Gov. Mike DeWine, Sen. Jon Husted, Secretary of State Frank LaRose, Iowa Senate candidate Rep. Ashley Hinson and Nikki Haley all criticized it. When a party’s own governor, senator and election chief recoil, the tactic has crossed from hardball into something indecent. That it ran at all tells you how desperate the closing stretch has become.
Get Involved Today
Contribute to our mission and turn your concerns into action.
IV. Twelve Billion Dollars and a Handful of Men
Behind the tricks sits the money, and the money has never been bigger. OpenSecrets projects federal spending this cycle at roughly $12 billion, making it the most expensive midterm on record. AdImpact puts political advertising at $11.6 billion, CNBC reports, versus $8.9 billion in the 2022 midterms and above even the $11.2 billion of the 2024 presidential cycle.
Those figures come from the Brennan Center for Justice, which found that Musk’s spending shattered both his own 2024 record of $290 million and the previous midterm record of $179 million set by George Soros in 2022. In the third quarter alone, Musk put more than $276 million into federal political groups, including $158 million to the Senate Leadership Fund and $89 million to his own America PAC, according to CNBC.
Big donors give to Democrats too, and we say so plainly. But the structure of this cycle is unmistakable: Democratic candidates are out-raising their opponents from ordinary people, while Republicans are being carried by a few billionaires writing nine-figure checks to super PACs. That is the same Senate Leadership Fund whose cash surfaced behind Alaska’s fringe-candidate blitz.
V. Trump’s Gerrymander Gamble
When Trump’s approval began sliding in 2025, he did not change course. He ordered Republican legislatures to redraw congressional maps mid-decade, a practice that until recently was rare and usually court-ordered. As Tom Schaller detailed at Public Notice, Texas, Florida, North Carolina, Ohio and Tennessee redrew; California answered with its own new map. The push failed in Indiana, where Republican state senators rebuked the President, and in Missouri, where the GOP map was ultimately rejected.
The early conventional wisdom held that this had bought the GOP a House cushion. That wisdom has eroded with Trump’s approval rating: analysts now peg net Republican gains from redistricting anywhere from six seats to none, and Sabato’s Crystal Ball analyst Kyle Kondik estimates two to five. Pollster Matt Barreto of BSP Research identified Latino-influenced seats Republicans drew expecting to win, including Texas’s 9th, 15th and 35th and Florida’s 9th, 27th and 13th, as places where backlash over ICE raids and the cost of living could flip them.
Honesty requires a caveat Kondik himself raises: a true “dummymander,” a map that loses more seats than the old one would have, may be rare, because many seats Republicans lose would likely have flipped under the old lines too. The better description is that Trump tried to buy seats he could not win on the merits, and a wave appears to be swamping the purchase. Gerrymandering cannot cure unpopularity.
VI. Fact-Checks Nobody Sees
Fact-checkers have done their jobs this cycle. FactCheck.org exposed the Acton ad. Reporters have repeatedly documented the emptiness of Trump’s fraud claims. The problem is not the absence of fact-checks; it is that they arrive late, travel slowly and are drowned out by the claims themselves, while the White House works to shrink the press corps that produces them.
In September, Trump defended banning CNN and two other outlets from the White House, insisting the press owed him coverage of his accomplishments, and then cited achievements that do not exist, including having settled “eight wars” and trillions of dollars supposedly pouring in. Meanwhile, the Alaska story was treated as a scandal of equal or greater weight than a sitting President ordering his Justice Department to pre-emptively contest a Senate result. A press culture that weighs a campaign trick and an assault on certification on the same scale is not being balanced. It is being played.
VII. The Grassroots Answer
Against the billionaires stands something money cannot buy: millions of people giving what they can. ActBlue reported that in the third quarter of 2026 small-dollar donors gave $833 million, its best non-presidential quarter ever and up 29 percent from the same quarter of 2022. More than 3 million donors made some 19 million contributions, averaging $44 apiece.
That is the signature of a movement, not a donor list. It is also why Republicans have spent the cycle attacking the platform itself. When you cannot match people’s enthusiasm, you try to delegitimize the pipes it flows through.
VIII. Record Turnout, and What It Signals
The energy is showing up at the polls. According to the University of Florida Election Lab, a record 51.3 million ballots were cast before Election Day, compared with 45.9 million in all of 2022. In-person early votes topped 28 million, up from about 20.5 million, and Democrats improved their early turnout in 16 of 25 states reporting party data. Election Lab director Michael McDonald said the early numbers suggest overall turnout is shaping up to match 2018, the highest-turnout midterm in more than a century.
Forecasters see a wave. Sabato’s Crystal Ball issued its final ratings today with 239 House seats at least leaning Democratic to 196 Republican, a 53–47 Democratic lean in the Senate and a 28–22 Democratic edge among governors. It moved Ohio, Maine, Texas and Kansas Senate races toward Democrats. Republicans can still outperform the polls on Election Day, when their voters traditionally turn out, and every vote still has to be cast. But if these numbers hold, Americans will have delivered a verdict on Trump’s governance that no lawsuit can erase.
IX. “Mr. Veto” and the War on the Count
Which brings us to what comes next. The President has already announced how he will respond to a Democratic Congress: not by governing, but by refusing to. In an interview with the New York Post, he said he would become “Mr. Veto,” and he went further.
“If we didn’t win … I’d veto everything.”
— President Donald Trump, via Newsweek
Read that again. Before a single bill exists, before he knows whether it lowers drug prices, protects Social Security or funds disaster relief, the President has pre-committed to rejecting it. A veto is a constitutional tool for judging legislation on its merits. Promising to use it on everything, sight unseen, is an admission that the merits do not matter and that the people’s vote does not either.
The veto is the soft half of the plan. The hard half is already in motion. As CNN has reported, the Justice Department has launched last-minute efforts to cast doubt on elections in California and Washington on dubious fraud theories, and Attorney General Todd Blanche will not rule out contesting results. Courts have rebuffed these efforts again and again, and on the eve of the election the Supreme Court denied the DOJ’s bid to segregate California ballots. Expect the next phase to target certification and the seating of winners, with Alaska as the test case, as The New Republic has warned.
What does this say about his priorities? A leader worried about the country would spend election eve preparing to work with whoever voters send to Washington. This President is preparing to obstruct them, prosecute his opponents and litigate the count. That is not leadership. It is a protection racket for his own power.
What the Constitution Actually Allows Him to Do
§1 · The Elections Clause (Art. I, § 4)
The Constitution gives states the power to set the times, places and manner of congressional elections, and lets Congress, not the President, alter those rules. There is no presidential power to “segregate” ballots or block certification. That is why every court to rule on the DOJ’s Alaska and California gambits has turned them away.
§2 · Seating Members (Art. I, § 5)
Each chamber judges the elections and qualifications of its own members. But in Powell v. McCormack (1969), the Supreme Court held that the House could not exclude a duly elected member who met the Constitution’s stated qualifications of age, citizenship and residency. A Senate majority that refused to seat a properly certified winner because it disliked how her opponent’s namesake got on the ballot would be on exceptionally weak constitutional ground.
§3 · The Veto (Art. I, § 7)
The veto is a check, not a strike. Congress may override with two-thirds of each chamber. Promising to veto “everything” turns a deliberative safeguard into a blanket refusal to govern, and it invites Congress to use every other tool it holds: oversight, appropriations and the power of the purse.
§4 · State Law Governs Ballot Access
Whether the Petersburg Sullivan belonged on the ballot was a question of Alaska law, and Alaska’s courts answered it. If anyone violated a statute in recruiting him, prosecutors can act, under the same rules that should apply to anyone who propped up Eric Hafner or a fringe Green. Selective outrage is not law enforcement.
X. What You Can Do
Polls open today, November 3. If you have not voted, there is still time, and if you have, there is still work. Here is what matters most in the next 72 hours and the weeks after.
- Vote, and bring three people with youCheck your registration and polling place with your state’s official election office or at vote.gov. Remember that Election Day is when Republicans traditionally close the gap; early-vote leads are not victories.
- In Alaska, rank your ballot fullyRanked-choice voting is the built-in antidote to spoilers. Read every name carefully and rank every candidate you can, so your vote follows your true preferences.
- Report intimidation, don’t argue with itIf you see voter intimidation or interference, contact the nonpartisan Election Protection hotline at 866-OUR-VOTE and your local election officials. Document what you see; let professionals respond.
- Be patient with the countClose races, mail ballots and ranked-choice tabulation take time. A slow count is a careful count. Refuse to amplify “fraud” claims made before ballots are tallied, from anyone.
- Hold the Senate to the ConstitutionCall your senators now and tell them you expect every certified winner, in Alaska and everywhere else, to be seated on January 3, regardless of party.
Editorial Conclusion
Ballot stacking is wrong, and anyone who broke the law to do it should answer for it. But the Republican Party, which bankrolled spoilers in this very race, smeared a survivor of child sexual abuse and gerrymandered on command, has no standing to lecture anyone about clean elections.
The real danger in Alaska is not a retired schoolteacher’s name on a ballot. It is a President who would use one candidate’s misconduct as a pretext to override voters, deny a certified winner her seat and veto a Congress before it passes a single law. Today, Americans decide who holds power. The obligation of every official, from county clerks to the Senate majority leader, is to honor that decision. Count every vote. Certify every result. Seat every winner. Anything less is not politics. It is the abandonment of self-government.
Sources & References
- Alaska Public Media — Peltola campaign and national Dems recruited spoiler candidates, according to New York Times
- PBS NewsHour — Trump calls for prosecution of Alaska Senate candidate Peltola over Sullivan name controversy
- NBC News — Federal judge dismisses Trump attempt to intervene in Alaska Senate race
- Alaska Beacon — Revealed: The money behind the last-minute fringe candidate ad blitz
- Alaska Beacon — Alaska’s U.S. House election includes a last-days push against a candidate in federal prison
- The New Republic — Inside Trump’s plot to keep the Senate in GOP hands even if Dems win
- NBC4 Columbus — GOP-connected group now spending $1.8M to support socialist in Ohio Senate race
- FactCheck.org — Controversial Ohio ad calls Acton a ‘liar,’ but records back her account
- CNN — The 2026 campaign is getting ugly — especially on the right
- Brennan Center for Justice — Big money breaks records, boosts GOP: 5 things to know
- CNBC — Midterm money takeaways: Democrats have candidate cash, Republicans have Elon Musk
- ABC News — Live updates: Supreme Court denies Trump bid to segregate California votes
- Public Notice — Dumb and dummymander (Tom Schaller)
- CNN — Trump criticizes the press for failing to report fake accomplishments
- ActBlue / PR Newswire — ActBlue Q3 2026: best non-presidential quarter to date
- Scripps News — In-person early voting hits record pace for midterms
- Wisconsin Examiner / States Newsroom — Early voting sets midterms record, breaking 2022 mark
- Sabato’s Crystal Ball — The final 2026 ratings: Democrats favored to capture House, Senate and governorships
- Newsweek — Trump says he’ll become ‘Mr. Veto’ if Democrats win midterms
- CNN — Analysis: All signs point to Trump contesting the election



