
On Election Day itself, the Department of Justice mailed criminal target letters to Democrats, flooded polling places with a record army of federal monitors, and won a 6–5 appellate ruling freeing it to threaten the officials who count our votes. No evidence of crime has been put before any court. That is not law enforcement. It is the scaffolding for overturning an election.
There was a time when the Justice Department went quiet in the weeks before an election, precisely so that no one could accuse it of putting a thumb on the scale. That era ended today. While Alaskans were still standing in line to vote in one of the closest Senate races in the country, federal prosecutors were notifying roughly two dozen Democrats that they may be targets of a criminal grand jury. Among them, according to CBS News, is Marc Elias, the country’s most prominent Democratic election lawyer — the man whose firm has beaten Donald Trump in court more often than anyone alive. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, CBS reports, has separately been hit with a grand jury subpoena.
Taken alone, any one of the day’s events would be alarming. Taken together — the target letters, the threats against election officials, the attempt to freeze certification in Alaska, the federal lists of “suspected noncitizens” riddled with actual citizens, and a monitoring operation concentrated in Democratic and minority communities — they form a pattern Americans have seen before. In 2020 it was a mob at the Capitol and a pressure campaign on state officials. In 2026 it wears a badge and carries a subpoena.
I. Alaska: Prosecuting the Opposition on Election Day
The pretext is a second man named Dan Sullivan. Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, qualified for the ballot alongside the Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan Sullivan, who is locked in a tight race with Democrat Mary Peltola. Republicans say he is a Democratic plant meant to siphon votes. Alaska’s courts — including the state Supreme Court — heard that argument and kept him on the ballot anyway. Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC deny any connection to his candidacy.
The Trump administration was not satisfied with that answer. According to The New York Times, as summarized by Election Law Blog, the department began sending letters to about 20 Democrats warning that they might be targets, a move the Times described as highly unusual at the decisive moment of a close race. ABC News reports the letters point to a grand jury probing possible conspiracy and donor-fraud offenses, and characterizes the step as unusual this early in an investigation.
Here is the problem the department cannot escape: federal prosecutors have not said what crime they are investigating. CBS reports exactly that. The closest thing to a theory came not from a prosecutor but from White House aide Stephen Miller, who floated on Fox News a federal civil-rights conspiracy statute written to punish those who intimidate citizens out of their rights. Meanwhile, as both CBS and the Times note, ballot-stacking — recruiting candidates to split an opponent’s vote — is a tactic both parties have used for generations and is generally not considered illegal.
“We will not be intimidated by a sham investigation.”
— Marc Elias, Elias Law Group, statement to CBS News
The president, for his part, has not bothered to wait for a grand jury. Over the weekend Trump publicly accused Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer and Elias of orchestrating a fraud and said they should face criminal charges, according to CBS. When the head of state names the defendants and the Justice Department then mails them target letters on Election Day, the public is entitled to ask who is running the investigation. Former federal prosecutor Harry Litman put it bluntly to Raw Story: “A target letter for what?” He argued the timing was deliberate — chosen while ballots were still being cast — and that it hands Republicans a ready-made pretext to contest a Sullivan loss.
CBS also reports the timing appears to collide with the department’s own internal guidelines limiting overt investigative steps near an election, and that some career prosecutors in Alaska declined or expressed discomfort when asked to join the probe. When the professionals are stepping back, the politics are stepping forward.
II. The Certification Gambit: “Count It Only If Our Man Wins”
The criminal probe is the second act. The first was a civil lawsuit — one Trump openly said he ordered, per the Associated Press — asking a federal court to bar Alaska from certifying its Senate result if Peltola narrowly wins. Read that again: the federal government asked a court to block certification only if a particular candidate lost. The AP noted that the complaint was signed by Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, who represented January 6 defendants and Trump allies before joining the department.
Alaska’s own Republican-run elections office fought back. In its filing, reported by Alaska Public Media, the state said the suit had no legal basis and warned that conditional certification would itself threaten election integrity. Notre Dame election-law scholar Derek Muller told the AP: “The statute simply doesn’t let the Department of Justice enjoin certification.” On Sunday, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case for lack of standing.
The suit was always weak law. That was never the point. A dismissed lawsuit still leaves behind a public record of “irregularities,” and a criminal probe announced on Election Day still leaves behind headlines about “fraud.” Those are the raw materials of a stolen-election narrative, manufactured in advance.
III. The Evidence Gap
Strip away the press conferences and the social-media posts, and ask a simple question of each front in this campaign: What has the government actually proven in court? The answer, across the board, is almost nothing.
Alaska Criminal Probe
No charges, and per CBS, no articulated crime. The U.S. Attorney cited a newspaper report as the basis for his surge of agents.
Alaska Certification Suit
Dismissed for lack of standing. Alaska argued the only statute cited — the National Voter Registration Act — governs registration, not counting (Alaska Public Media).
California’s ~21,000 Voters
Secretary of State Shirley Weber said DOJ supplied no methodology for flagging names (Democracy Docket). Judge Boasberg found the list included citizens.
The Supreme Court’s Answer
After losses in district court and twice at the Ninth Circuit, the justices rejected DOJ’s emergency bid in one sentence, without even asking California to respond (Democracy Docket).
“Noncitizen” Lists
Judge Tanya Chutkan found the lists likely violated federal privacy and rulemaking law and barred DOJ from sharing them or directing states to act on them (Democracy Docket).
Voter-Roll Lawsuits
DOJ sued 26 states that refused to hand over voter rolls; federal judges dismissed every one of those suits as unlawful (Courthouse News).
To be fair to the record: the department has announced charges against a small number of individual noncitizens accused of illegal voting, and nobody disputes that such cases should be prosecuted when proven. But a handful of individual cases cannot justify freezing tens of thousands of ballots on the strength of a list that judges found contains citizens. In his order, Judge James Boasberg noted that an immigrant-rights group had identified multiple members who are citizens but were wrongly included — and that flawed data created a real risk that some county officials would bow to federal pressure and hold up lawful ballots.
IV. Threats Against the People Who Count the Votes
The quieter campaign may prove more dangerous than the loud one. Days before the election, the Office of the Deputy Attorney General sent letters to election officials in all 50 states reminding them of records-retention duties and pointedly citing penalties of up to a year in prison, according to Democracy Docket. In California, the threats went further: officials were told to sequester ballots or face the consequences.
A coalition including the NAACP, LULAC and labor unions sued, and U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson agreed the threats likely violated federal law. Then the whiplash began. Early Tuesday, the Ninth Circuit restored Thompson’s order. By Tuesday afternoon — in the middle of Election Day — an 11-judge en banc panel reversed course by a single vote, as Democracy Docket reported. Writing for the 6–5 majority, Trump appointee Judge Eric Miller described the department’s letters as merely “expressing its views about criminal statutes.”
That framing should chill anyone who has ever worked a polling place. A letter from the nation’s chief prosecutor, sent days before an election, invoking prison time unless you abandon state procedures in favor of the federal government’s preferred procedures, is not an academic opinion. Chief Judge Mary Murguia’s dissent made the point precisely: the majority’s ruling cannot be squared with the court’s own conclusion a week earlier that Washington had no authority to pressure states into not counting ballots. Now, she warned, federal officials may effectively compel compliance by threatening prosecution.
“This is outrageous, and we should be outraged about this.”
— David Becker, Center for Election Innovation & Research, on DOJ subpoenas timed for the day after the election
Becker, a former DOJ voting-rights lawyer, was responding to subpoenas demanding testimony from California election officials on November 4 — the day after the election, when those same officials will be finalizing counts. As he told Democracy Docket’s Jim Saksa, the evident goal is to pull officials away from their work so that counts appear slow — exactly the conditions in which false claims of fraud flourish.
V. A Federal Presence at the Polls — In All 50 States
For the first time in American history, the Justice Department deployed monitors to every state: roughly 1,000 monitors and observers, according to Axios. For comparison, Newsweek counts 289 monitors in the 2022 midterms and 714 in the 2024 presidential race. Federal monitoring is a legitimate tool born of the Voting Rights Act — designed to protect minority voters from intimidation. The question is where this administration aimed it. Courthouse News found that of 126 jurisdictions listed, roughly two-thirds voted for Kamala Harris in 2024, with deployments heavily weighted toward Black and Latino communities.
And by midday, the warnings were already coming in. New Mexico’s Secretary of State told a reporter that verified DOJ monitors in Bernalillo County had been asking unusual questions and questioning voters — conduct the state says the law does not allow, according to Raw Story. In Michigan, the Michigan Advance reports that Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson’s office contacted the department after monitors in Dearborn and Flint questioned poll workers about their training — conduct state officials said fell outside the monitors’ authority and that a DOJ coordinator conceded was inconsistent with how monitors were trained. (Michigan officials also noted that monitors who spoke with voters in Lansing appeared to follow the rules.)
The administration’s legal posture makes these reports more troubling, not less. In litigation brought by the NAACP, the department argued that the Voting Rights Act’s ban on voter intimidation does not apply to the federal government at all, as Democracy Docket documented. Only after a federal judge pressed it did the department reverse itself and agree that no sworn, armed, uniformed officers with arrest powers would serve as monitors. Judge Reggie Walton, a George W. Bush appointee, ordered the department to honor that concession and warned that misrepresentations would mean “hell to pay.” A government that must be ordered not to send armed agents to polling places has told us what it was considering.
VI. How We Got Here: The Timeline
Get Involved Today
Contribute to our mission and turn your concerns into action.
VII. Are the Courts Holding the Line?
Mostly — and that word carries enormous weight. District judges appointed by presidents of both parties have rejected the administration’s schemes at nearly every turn, and the Supreme Court refused to rescue the California case. As Saksa wrote, the voter-suppression effort has been, so far, an unqualified failure in court.
But democracy is not protected by a winning percentage. It is protected by the absence of exceptions, and today the Ninth Circuit created one at the worst possible moment. A single vote on an appellate bench now permits the federal government to brandish prosecution against local officials during the most sensitive phase of the process: the count and the canvass. And as the Trump-appointed Judge Eric Tung’s dissent in a related case shows, the theory that the federal government is exempt from the voter-intimidation ban is gaining a foothold on the federal bench. Courts that move in days cannot always catch threats that land in hours.
The Law the Administration Is Asking Us to Forget
The Elections Clause (Art. I, § 4). The Constitution assigns the “Times, Places and Manner” of congressional elections to the states, subject only to laws passed by Congress — not directives from the executive branch. Alaska’s lawyers, citing a recent Supreme Court ruling, argued the United States lacks authority to intervene in state elections at all, much less on behalf of a favored candidate (Alaska’s News Source).
Section 11(b) of the Voting Rights Act (52 U.S.C. § 10307). Bars any “person, whether acting under color of law or otherwise,” from intimidating, threatening or coercing voters or those aiding them. The phrase “under color of law” was written to reach government actors. The administration’s claim that federal officials are exempt would leave the most powerful potential intimidator in the country the only one beyond the statute’s reach.
The National Voter Registration Act. The sole federal statute DOJ cited in Alaska governs voter registration. It says nothing about ballot counting or certification.
DOJ’s own election-year norms. Long-standing department practice counsels against overt investigative steps that could affect an election. CBS reports the Election Day target letters appear to run afoul of those guidelines.
The bottom line: Certification is a ministerial duty under state law, and the Twentieth Amendment sets January 3 as the start of the new Congress. No executive agency holds a veto over either. Any attempt to manufacture one — by lawsuit, subpoena or prosecution — is an attack on the constitutional order itself.
VIII. What This Says About Trump’s Priorities
A president confident in his record campaigns on it. A president who is not tries to change the electorate. Every tool in this campaign — the voter-roll demands, the “noncitizen” lists, the conditional-certification suit, the target letters, the monitors deployed to Democratic strongholds — shares a single purpose: to reduce the number of votes that count against him and his allies, or to create grounds to discard them later.
This is a government that, by its own account, holds the White House, both chambers of Congress and a majority of state legislatures. Its Justice Department has nonetheless spent the final weeks of a midterm campaign pursuing the president’s critics — a grand jury declined to indict former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson, and a magistrate judge tossed a complaint against former FBI officials as apparently politically motivated and timed to the midterms. Former Election Assistance Commission chair Ben Hovland warned that baseless litigation paired with false integrity narratives is a real danger to democracy. He is right. A leader who must win this way has already conceded that he cannot win the honest way.
IX. What You Can Do
The polls have closed, but the most dangerous phase — the count, the canvass, and certification — is still ongoing. That is where pressure has always been applied, and it is where citizens can still make a difference. Honestly assessed: the courts remain your strongest backstop, and they work best when abuses are documented quickly and specifically.
- Cure your ballot. If you voted by mail, check your state or county’s ballot-tracking site over the coming days. Signature or ID problems can often be fixed within a short window — but only if you act.
- Report intimidation to your state, not just Washington. Disruptions belong with local election officials; threats or intimidation belong with local police (911) and your secretary of state. In this environment, state officials are your first line of defense.
- Show up for the canvass. County canvassing and certification meetings are generally public. Attend, observe, and speak during public comment in support of certifying results on time and according to law.
- Call your senators and representative. Demand public oversight of the Election Day target letters, the monitor program, and the threat letters to election officials — and demand that they commit, on the record, to seat every lawfully certified winner on January 3.
Editorial Conclusion
January 6 was not a single day. It was a strategy — delegitimize the count, pressure the counters, and manufacture a pretext to reject the result. In 2026 that strategy has moved inside the Justice Department, and it began before the last ballot was cast.
The courts have largely held. Election officials of both parties have held. Now the American people must hold: every lawful vote counted, every certified result honored, every official who abuses the power of prosecution to stay in power held to account. A democracy that tolerates a government prosecuting its opposition on Election Day will not remain a democracy for long. That is the stake. Nothing less is required.
Sources & References
- CBS News — Marc Elias is a target of DOJ’s Alaska ballot investigation, sources say
- ABC News — DOJ ramps up probe of Alaska Senate race with target letters, new subpoenas
- Election Law Blog — DOJ sending target letters in Alaska probe, including to DSCC and Marc Elias
- Raw Story — ‘Five-alarm fire’ flagged as Trump DOJ hits Dems with target letters while votes cast
- Associated Press (via WLOX) — Trump says he ordered the Justice Department lawsuit over Alaska’s Senate race
- Alaska Public Media — State of Alaska says DOJ lawsuit over Senate race ‘has no legal basis’
- Alaska’s News Source / Alaska Beacon — Alaska fights back against Trump-ordered elections lawsuit
- Democracy Docket — 9th Circuit pauses order barring Trump administration from threatening election officials
- Democracy Docket — Trump admin reveals it’s challenged voters in 5 states, and threatened election officials in all 50
- Democracy Docket — Trump’s voter suppression crusade has failed. But his bid to subvert the midterms may just be getting started
- Democracy Docket — Judge blocks Trump administration from disenfranchising California voters
- Democracy Docket — Judge orders Trump administration to stop challenging votes with noncitizen lists
- Democracy Docket — Supreme Court’s blunt dismissal of Trump admin’s California ballots case
- Democracy Docket — California rejected DOJ’s ‘outrageous’ demand to vet thousands of alleged noncitizens
- Democracy Docket — Voter intimidation ban doesn’t apply to federal government, DOJ claims
- Democracy Docket — Judge won’t bar DOJ from deploying law enforcement to voting sites
- Axios — DOJ sending 1,000 election monitors to all 50 states
- Courthouse News Service — DOJ sends election monitors to all 50 states amid midterm voting
- Newsweek — Map shows where DOJ is deploying election monitors for midterms
- Michigan Advance — Michigan officials flag improper interactions between DOJ monitors and poll workers
- Raw Story — Trump DOJ poll monitors ‘doing things not allowed by law’: state election chief
- YouTube (video report) — Video coverage of the Alaska target letters



