
One Visit, Two Bills: Medicare’s Same-Day Cut and the Slow Dismantling of the Safety Net
Starting January 1, the Trump administration will pay doctors less when they examine a patient and treat the problem in the same appointment. The rule is small on paper. But it lands on seniors in the same season the administration has let health subsidies lapse, pushed Medicaid work requirements and tried again to zero out heating aid. Taken together, these choices show who this government is built to serve.
Picture a 74-year-old woman in a dermatologist’s office. She came in about a rash, and she mentions a dark spot on her shoulder that has been changing. Today, the doctor can examine the spot, decide it looks suspicious and biopsy it on the spot. She pays one copay and makes one trip, and the pathology results come back sooner. Starting January 1, Medicare will pay that doctor less for doing exactly that.
The change sits in the final 2027 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, which the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released on November 4. Under it, CMS will pay 20% less for the lower-paid service when a physician bills a separate office visit with a billing code called modifier 25 on the same day as a minor procedure. The rule does not order anyone to come back for a second appointment. But physicians across the country warn that it builds a financial incentive to do exactly that, and seniors will pay for it in copays, gas money and lost time.
I. What the Rule Actually Does
Modifier 25 is how a physician tells Medicare that an office visit was a significant, separately identifiable service from a procedure done the same day. The American Medical Association explains that the modifier typically applies when a patient with a new or worsening problem needs evaluation, diagnosis and decision-making, plus a procedure, in the same visit. That is the ordinary rhythm of medicine for older patients, who rarely arrive with only one problem.
The final version is narrower than what CMS first floated. According to Medical Economics, the July proposal would have paid the lower-paid same-day service at 50%, covered 10- and 90-day global surgical procedures, and applied to any physician in the same practice. The final rule cuts 20%, applies only to procedures with a “0-day” global period, and covers only the same physician or a same-specialty colleague in the same group. The higher-paid service is still paid in full.
The cut does not always fall on the office visit. The Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) notes that which line is reduced depends on the fee schedule amounts, not on which service is “primary.” In MGMA’s example, a standard office visit priced at about $93 paired with a nail debridement at about $44 means the procedure takes the haircut.
The Same-Day Cut
The lower-paid line is reduced when a modifier-25 office visit and a 0-day global procedure fall on the same day, per the final rule. CMS originally proposed 50%.
The Across-the-Board Cut
Most physicians face a 2.31% cut per relative value unit in 2027, a deeper reduction than CMS proposed in July, as reported by Medical Economics.
Hardest-Hit Specialties
CMS’s own impact analysis projects significant decreases for dermatology, otolaryngology, orthopedic surgery and hand surgery, largely because of the modifier-25 policy, per Medical Economics.
The Patient’s Bill
Pathologist Dr. Eric Wargotz warns in Medical Economics that splitting care means a second copay, another trip for patients who depend on family drivers, and slower diagnoses.
The Opposition
Seventy-four members of Congress signed a September 11 letter urging CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz not to finalize the cut, arguing CMS had not shown that same-day visits systematically duplicate procedure costs.
CMS’s Defense
CMS argues that when the same doctor does both services there are “efficiencies,” and Medicare is likely paying twice for overlapping work, according to the agency’s fact sheet as quoted by HFMA.
Get Involved Today
Contribute to our mission and turn your concerns into action.
II. Where It Came From — and Who Owns It
This idea is not new, and it is not an orphan. It belongs to the Trump administration twice over. The AMA recounts that CMS first proposed a similar same-day payment cut in July 2018, during President Trump’s first term, and dropped it after physicians and other stakeholders raised serious concerns. The 2027 version, the AMA noted, would have covered even more procedures than the 2019 attempt.
This time the policy carries the signature of CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz, serving under Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Oz framed the whole fee schedule as a moral crusade against waste. In a statement reported by Bloomberg Tax, he said the rule works by ending duplicate billing and closing costly loopholes to protect taxpayers.
“For too long, fee-for-service payment has rewarded volume over value, fueling a reactive system of sick care.”
— CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz, M.D., via Chief Healthcare Executive
The administration had allies. According to the Daily Signal, sixteen conservative groups led by the 60 Plus Association wrote to Oz in October backing the proposal. They pointed to federal audits that found tens of millions of dollars in improper payments involving same-day visits and procedures in fields such as ophthalmology and dermatology.
That concern deserves a fair hearing: billing abuse is real, and taxpayers should not pay twice for the same work. But there is a difference between going after improper claims and cutting payment for legitimate care. Physicians told CMS that tools already exist for the first job. The physician coalition’s letter, as reported by Becker’s ASC, notes that the RUC’s work surveys already exclude work tied to a distinct modifier-25 visit, and that CMS’s own misvalued-code process has already revalued codes commonly billed alongside same-day visits. The congressional letter makes the same point: overlapping costs are removed once already, and this rule removes them again.
AMA President Dr. Willie Underwood III put the problem plainly in a column quoted by the AMA:
“How does it make any sense to pay a physician less for doing what is right for their patients?”
— Willie Underwood III, M.D., President, American Medical Association
III. Is It Legal?
Bad policy and illegal policy are two different things. On the narrow legal question, the answer is uncomfortable for opponents: the rule is very likely lawful, and very hard to challenge in court.
Congress handed CMS the pen — and took away the courts’ eraser
1. The authority
Under the Medicare Act, physician payment is calculated by multiplying a service’s relative value, the year’s conversion factor and a geographic adjustment, as the Seventh Circuit summarized in American Society of Cataract & Refractive Surgery v. Thompson (2002). Congress delegated to the HHS Secretary the job of setting and revising those values each year. Deciding that two services delivered together cost less than two delivered separately sits squarely within that delegation.
2. The review bar
Congress also wrote into 42 U.S.C. § 1395w-4(i)(1)(B) that there shall be no administrative or judicial review of the determination of relative values. Courts have read that broadly. In Fischer v. Berwick (4th Cir. 2013), the court held that the bar covers not only the final values but also the process used to reach them.
3. The possible opening
The Fischer court, relying on Thompson, noted that “ancillary” policies applied after relative values are set may fall outside the bar. A claim-level reduction that applies only when two services share a date arguably works that way. If a court agreed, CMS would have to defend the rule under the Administrative Procedure Act, including why it reversed the position it took when it abandoned the same idea for 2019. The congressional letter argues the agency never produced evidence that same-day visits systematically duplicate costs. That is a viable theory, not a sure thing, and we are not aware of any lawsuit filed so far.
4. The power of the purse
The deeper constitutional question in this story is not the Medicare rule. It is the administration’s handling of money Congress has already appropriated. Article I gives Congress the power of the purse, and the Impoundment Control Act of 1974 requires the executive to spend appropriated funds unless Congress approves a rescission. As discussed below, more than $400 million in heating aid that Congress approved sat undistributed for months this year. Lawmakers should treat that as an oversight question, not just a budget dispute.
Bottom line
The same-day cut is probably legal. That is why the remedy has to be legislative. Congress wrote the statute that gave CMS this power, and only Congress can reliably take it back.
IV. What It Means for Seniors — and Everyone Else
For Medicare patients, the risk is fragmentation. Seventy-four lawmakers warned Oz in their letter that patients usually arrive with symptoms, not a planned procedure, and that the cut could split care into pieces, with rural communities hit hardest. Dr. Wargotz, a former president of Maryland’s state medical society, argues in Medical Economics that forcing separate visits would end up costing Medicare more overall, not less.
For everyone else, the stakes are structural. The modifier-25 cut stacks on top of a 2.31% across-the-board reduction. That cut follows largely from the expiration of a one-year 2.5% bump that Republicans wrote into their own 2025 reconciliation law, as Medical Economics reports. The American Academy of Family Physicians has noted, in a statement reported by Healio, that Medicare physician payments fell 33% from 2001 to 2025 after adjusting for inflation. Independent practices that cannot absorb more cuts sell to hospital systems or private equity, or they close. That consolidation raises prices for every American with insurance, not just those on Medicare. The AMA warned the cut is a particular threat to independent practices.
V. A Pattern, Not an Accident
Read in isolation, a 20% cut on one line of a Medicare claim could be dismissed as technocratic housekeeping. It should not be read in isolation. It arrives at the end of a year in which this administration and its congressional allies have taken, or tried to take, something from nearly every group of Americans living close to the edge.
Health insurance. According to KFF, Marketplace enrollment hit a record 21.8 million in 2025, largely because of the enhanced tax credits, before their expiration drove up costs and pushed enrollment down in 2026. Insurers are now seeking a median premium increase of about 15% for 2027. CBS News reported that the average subsidized enrollee’s annual premium payment could more than double, from about $888 to $1,904.
Medicaid. On January 1, adults covered through Medicaid expansion must start proving work or other qualifying activity to keep their coverage. The Congressional Budget Office projected that the work requirements alone would leave 5.3 million more people uninsured by 2034, as reported by TechTarget. KFF notes that CBO expects few of those dropped to have access to employer coverage.
Heat. The Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program helps roughly 6 million households a year. While the funds were held up, OMB communications director Rachel Cauley called the program fraud-ridden without offering evidence, POLITICO reported. The HHS audits the administration pointed to found weak monitoring in Michigan and New York, not fraud. Republican Senate Appropriations Chair Susan Collins led 40 senators in demanding the money be released. Now the National Energy Assistance Directors Association projects that heating oil costs could jump 50% this winter. Sen. Peter Welch of Vermont said of the program: “This is not a luxury. It can be a matter of life and death.”
VI. Congress: Bipartisan Letters, a Lame-Duck Clock
Opposition to the same-day cut is unusually bipartisan. The first two signatures on the 74-member letter belong to Reps. John Joyce and Greg Murphy, both Republican physicians. The administration finalized the cut anyway, which tells you how much weight it gives even its own party’s doctors.
Democrats have spent the year tying physician pay to the larger affordability crisis. At a May hearing, House Energy and Commerce ranking member Frank Pallone Jr. blamed what he called the Republicans’ “Big Ugly Bill” for cutting more than $1 trillion from Americans’ health care, and he insisted that any Medicare payment fix must not raise what beneficiaries pay out of pocket, according to his prepared remarks.
Then the voters spoke. On November 3, Democrats won both chambers, the first time the opposition has controlled both during a Republican presidency since 2006, according to Becker’s Hospital Review. House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries had promised in October that his caucus would be united around reversing the Medicaid cuts and extending the ACA tax credits. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer summed up the message to voters in five words: “Relief is on the way.”
But the new majorities do not take power until January, and the same-day cut starts January 1. The real window is the lame-duck session, which runs to December 11, when government funding expires, per the AMA. The AMA and 61 other health care organizations are asking Congress to use that funding bill to delay the modifier-25 cut for one year, continue the 2026 payment update, and pass the bipartisan Provider Reimbursement Stability Act. In the Senate, sixteen Democrats have asked leadership to attach a two-year delay of Medicaid work requirements to the next legislative vehicle.
So far, Republican leaders still running this Congress have not committed to any of it. Every day they wait is a day closer to January 1.
VII. The President’s Priorities
We could find no public statement from President Trump about the same-day visit cut. That silence fits a pattern. When he unveiled his “Great Healthcare Plan” in January, his message was that “the government is going to pay the money directly to you,” as the Associated Press reported. He offered no dollar amount and no plan for the expired credits. Healthcare Dive reported that 70% of experts surveyed by a Cornell health policy center said swapping the enhanced subsidies for health savings account deposits would measurably worsen affordability.
And when voters handed his party a historic defeat, the President’s first extended public remarks were about a building. On November 4, the Associated Press reported, he responded to the losses by showing off his White House ballroom and signing a steel beam, in a display the AP described as the kind of detachment voters cited as a reason for their votes. Asked about the results, he told reporters, “If I were on the ballot, we would have won,” and before the election he had vowed to brand himself a veto president if Democrats took Congress, according to NBC News. KFF’s Larry Levitt told NBC that Trump is bound to veto any bill rolling back the Medicaid cuts.
Put the pieces side by side. A ballroom is going up at the White House. The administration finalized a pay cut for doctors who treat seniors in one visit, called heating aid fraud without proof, and let millions of families’ insurance premiums double. It also built paperwork hurdles that CBO expects will push millions off Medicaid. This is what the administration has chosen to protect and what it has chosen to cut.
VIII. What Comes Next for the Vulnerable
January 1, 2027 will be one of the hardest New Year’s Days in recent memory for Americans living on the margins. Seniors face a Medicare system that pays their doctors less for same-day care. Low-income adults in the 40-plus expansion states face new work-reporting rules. Families shopping for Marketplace coverage face higher premiums, with open enrollment ending January 15 in most states. And households heating with oil face a winter of soaring prices while the White House argues that the program helping them should not exist.
The new Democratic Congress has real tools: must-pass funding bills, oversight hearings, the ability to restore ACA credits retroactively, and the subpoena power to examine how appropriated funds were handled. Levitt told NBC that a deal restoring the enhanced subsidies could be backdated to the start of 2027, so people who paid higher premiums would get refunds. But as Managed Healthcare Executive noted, Trump’s veto limits what Democrats can undo on their own. Relief will come only if public pressure makes obstruction more costly than compromise.
IX. What You Can Do
the same-day cut is final, it is likely legal, and courts are unlikely to stop it. The most realistic win before January 1 is a one-year delay in the December funding bill. Beyond that, your best protection is knowing your rights and using the deadlines that remain.
Call Congress before December 11
Ask your senators and representative to support a one-year delay of the modifier-25 cut and an extension of the 2026 physician payment update in the year-end funding bill. These are the specific asks from the AMA’s lame-duck agenda. The U.S. Capitol switchboard is (202) 224-3121.
Ask your doctor directly
If you are on Medicare and are asked to return for a procedure, ask whether the second visit is medically necessary or a scheduling choice. The rule does not require two visits. If a same-specialty doctor in the same group splits your care, it is fair to ask why, and to request same-day treatment where it is safe.
Shop the Marketplace before January 15
If you buy your own insurance, compare plans now rather than auto-renewing. Open enrollment ends January 15, 2027 in most states, and on December 15 in Idaho, per ABC News. Keep your premium records in case Congress restores credits retroactively.
Document now if you’re on Medicaid
If you are covered through Medicaid expansion, contact your state Medicaid agency to learn exactly how work or exemption status must be reported. Start keeping pay stubs, school enrollment records or volunteer logs before January 1.
Apply for heating help early
LIHEAP funds can run out mid-winter. Apply as soon as your state’s program opens, usually through your local community action agency. Ask your utility about winter shutoff protections. Then tell your members of Congress to fully fund LIHEAP for FY2027, as Rep. Chris Pappas and 73 colleagues have demanded.
Editorial Conclusion
A government shows its values in small rules as much as in grand speeches. Paying doctors less for treating an elderly patient in one visit is a small rule. It sits beside larger ones: lapsed insurance credits, Medicaid paperwork designed to shed enrollees, and a sixth attempt to end heating aid. Together they show an administration that treats the vulnerable as a line item to be trimmed while a ballroom rises outside the Oval Office.
Congress has the authority to stop the same-day cut before it starts, and it must use it in the December funding bill. The incoming majority must then use every constitutional tool it has, including the power of the purse, oversight and the subpoena, to restore what was taken. Medicare, Medicaid and the heat in a senior’s home are not favors a president grants. They are promises the people made to one another through their laws. America has had enough of watching those promises broken one rule at a time.
Sources & References
- Medical Economics — Medicare’s final 2027 fee schedule cuts physician pay more than proposed but softens the same-day visit penalty (Nov. 4, 2026)
- Medical Economics — Why Medicare’s 20% modifier 25 cut still penalizes same-day care (Nov. 10, 2026)
- American Medical Association — 2027 proposed Medicare fee schedule: What physicians need to know
- American Medical Association — Lame-duck session offers chance to protect Medicare patients’ access
- American Medical Association — AMA, 61 healthcare organizations ask Congress for four Medicare reforms
- U.S. House of Representatives (via AAO-HNS) — Congressional letter to CMS Administrator Oz on Modifier 25 (Sept. 11, 2026)
- MGMA — Modifier 25 in 2027: Billing office visits and zero-day procedures
- Chief Healthcare Executive — CMS’ final 2027 physician fee schedule cuts pay and reworks ACO incentives
- Bloomberg Tax — Medicare agency updates cuts to doctor pay after temporary boost
- HFMA — 2027 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule cuts persist despite CMS concessions
- Becker’s ASC Review — A 50% Medicare cut has physicians sounding the alarm
- The Daily Signal — Conservative coalition urges Dr. Oz to end Medicare’s ‘paying twice’ problem (Oct. 9, 2026)
- Healio — CMS announces 2027 Medicare pay cut as ACR decries ‘breaking point’ for physicians
- U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Cir. (Justia) — American Society of Cataract & Refractive Surgery v. Thompson, 279 F.3d 447 (2002)
- U.S. Court of Appeals, 4th Cir. (Justia) — Fischer v. Berwick, No. 12-1713 (2013)
- KFF — Midterm Election Update: The Affordable Care Act Marketplaces
- KFF — ACA Marketplace Enrollment is Down in 2026—But All of the Data Isn’t in Yet
- CBS News — Far fewer Americans enrolled in ACA plans after subsidies expired
- KFF — A Closer Look at the Work Requirement Provisions in the 2025 Federal Budget Reconciliation Law
- TechTarget — Breaking down uninsured numbers under Trump’s spending law
- POLITICO (via Action for Boston Community Development) — Trump holds back federal aid for Americans’ energy bills
- Roll Call — Lawmakers buck calls to defund low-income heating program
- NEADA — Heating oil costs expected to jump 50% this winter as global diesel prices surge
- Office of Sen. Peter Welch — Welch slams Trump’s proposal to eliminate federal home energy assistance program
- Office of Rep. Chris Pappas — Pappas leads opposition to Trump’s elimination of home energy assistance program
- House Energy & Commerce Democrats — Opening statement of Ranking Member Frank Pallone Jr. (May 20, 2026)
- Becker’s Hospital Review — Democrats gain control of Congress: 5 midterm takeaways for healthcare leaders
- Boston 25 News — Election 2026: Democrats capture both chambers of Congress
- Nextgov — Democratic Congress likely to scrutinize Medicaid work requirements, Medicare AI test
- Associated Press (via Iron Mountain Daily News) — Trump announces outlines of health care plan
- States Newsroom (Michigan Advance) — Trump rolls out framework on health care costs that’s silent on ACA tax credits
- Healthcare Dive — Trump unveils ‘Great Healthcare Plan’
- Associated Press (via WDBO) — Trump brags about his White House ballroom and seeks to deflect blame for GOP midterm drubbing
- NBC News (NBC Los Angeles) — Day after the 2026 midterms: live updates
- Managed Healthcare Executive — A Democratic Congress likely means more oversight for payers, not a Medicaid rollback
- ABC News — With premiums on the rise, what to know as ACA open enrollment begins



