Sixty Votes to Nowhere: It Is Time to End the Filibuster

Born of a clerical accident, sharpened into a weapon against civil rights, and now wielded to smother nearly every bill the public asks for, the filibuster has turned the world’s “greatest deliberative body” into a chamber that barely deliberates at all. Democrats have just won the Senate. The question is whether their leaders will finally let the majority govern — or keep handing a veto to the losers.

The United States Senate does not have a rule that says legislation needs sixty votes. It never did. What it has is a gap — a missing rule — that a determined minority has learned to exploit until the exception swallowed the institution. For most of the last two decades, that gap has quietly decided which problems the American government is allowed to solve. Wages, voting rights, abortion rights, gun safety, immigration, climate: each has died not on an up-or-down vote, but in the procedural fog where forty-one senators, sometimes representing a small fraction of the country, can stop the rest from ever voting at all.

Now the ground has shifted. In last week’s midterms, Democrats flipped at least seven Republican-held seats and took back the Senate, with Chuck Schumer touting “55 seats and counting.” Within days, Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen announced he would challenge Schumer for majority leader — and on Friday he made the filibuster the defining line of that race. Meanwhile, President Trump, whose own party is about to lose power, is demanding the lame-duck Republican majority do exactly what he has spent years warning Democrats against. The filibuster’s future has never been more openly contested. It is time to settle it.

I. An Accident With a Body Count

The most persistent myth about the filibuster is that the Framers designed it. They did not. As Brookings scholar Sarah Binder told the Senate Rules Committee, the House and Senate began in 1789 with nearly identical rulebooks, both containing a “previous question” motion that let a simple majority cut off debate. The House kept it. The Senate threw it away — not to protect minority rights, but because Vice President Aaron Burr, then presiding over the chamber, advised senators to tidy up a rulebook he considered cluttered. In 1806 they dropped the motion. Binder’s verdict is blunt: the filibuster appears to have been created by mistake.

Historians still argue about how much blame Burr deserves; the National Constitution Center notes that political scientist Gregory Koger places more responsibility on later Senate majorities that never bothered to restore majority cloture. But on the core point there is no dispute: the filibuster is a by-product, not a blueprint. Nothing in the Constitution requires it, and for decades after 1806 senators rarely used the loophole at all.

When they did start using it, they used it for the worst causes in American history. The Brennan Center for Justice traces early filibusters to pro-slavery senators like John C. Calhoun, and the tactic’s twentieth-century signature was the defense of Jim Crow. In 1917, with President Woodrow Wilson pressing for action, the Senate adopted Rule XXII — cloture — which allowed debate to be ended, but only with a two-thirds supermajority. As Arizona State political scientist Steven Smith told PolitiFact, Wilson’s backing of that first workaround shows how much a president’s pressure can matter.

The bar was high, and segregationists exploited it ruthlessly. In 1957 Strom Thurmond, then a South Carolina Democrat, spoke for 24 hours and 18 minutes against the Civil Rights Act of 1957 — still the longest solo filibuster on record. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 cleared the Senate only after cloture was invoked to end a filibuster that dragged on for some 60 days. Anti-lynching bills died in the Senate for generations. When Barack Obama, eulogizing John Lewis in 2020, called the filibuster “another Jim Crow relic,” he was not reaching for a metaphor. He was summarizing the record.

  • 1806On Aaron Burr’s advice, the Senate drops the “previous question” motion — the only tool that let a simple majority end debate.
  • 1917Under pressure from Woodrow Wilson, the Senate adopts Rule XXII (cloture), requiring a two-thirds vote to cut off debate.
  • August 1957Strom Thurmond filibusters for 24 hours, 18 minutes against the Civil Rights Act of 1957.
  • June 1964The Senate finally invokes cloture on the Civil Rights Act after a roughly 60-day Southern filibuster.
  • 1975Cloture threshold lowered to 60 votes — but the “silent” filibuster means no one has to hold the floor anymore.
  • November 2013Harry Reid’s Democrats end the filibuster for executive and lower-court nominees after Republicans block three D.C. Circuit judges.
  • April 2017Mitch McConnell’s Republicans extend the “nuclear option” to the Supreme Court to confirm Neil Gorsuch.
  • January 2022A narrow rules change to pass voting-rights bills fails 52–48 as Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema join every Republican.
  • September 2025Senate GOP goes nuclear again, allowing unlimited sub-Cabinet nominees to be confirmed en bloc by simple majority.
  • Oct. 2025 – Nov. 2026Trump repeatedly demands Republicans “terminate” the filibuster — first to end a shutdown, now to beat a Democratic majority to the punch.

II. From Last Resort to Default Setting

The filibuster most Americans picture — Jimmy Stewart hoarse on the Senate floor — barely exists anymore. Since the early 1970s, the Brennan Center explains, senators have relied on a “silent” filibuster: if 41 members merely signal opposition, the majority leader typically declines to bring the bill up at all. No speeches. No exhaustion. No public cost. The minority does not have to defend its obstruction; it only has to announce it.

The result is a Senate in which the supermajority is not reserved for extraordinary questions but applied to virtually everything. A 2012 Brennan Center study, Curbing Filibuster Abuse, found that the Senate filed more cloture motions in the six years after 2006 than in the seven decades between 1917 and 1988 combined. Both parties have played this game; the arms race only accelerates. And the casualties are not abstract. When Democrats last held a filibuster-proof caucus — a window the Center Square notes lasted only from April 2009 to February 2010 — they still had to shrink the economic stimulus and water down the Affordable Care Act to satisfy the most reluctant member, compromises that writer Mitchell Zimmerman, writing for Nation of Change, argues left millions worse off and denied Democrats credit for the recovery.

Cloture Explosion

2,500+

Votes to end a filibuster since 1917 — more than half of them crammed into a single recent twelve-year span, by the Brennan Center’s count.

Seventy Years in Six

385

Cloture motions filed from 2006 to 2012 — more than the Senate filed in the entire 1917–1988 period, per Curbing Filibuster Abuse.

The Rare Supermajority

~10 months

The last time either party held 60 Senate seats: April 2009 to February 2010, as the Center Square documents. The “normal” Senate is one where the majority cannot legislate.

The Silent Veto

41

Senators needed to block a bill without saying a word on the floor. The mere threat, the Brennan Center warns, kills debate and the incentive to compromise.

Power Drains to the President

Unchecked

Congressional paralysis has pushed presidents to govern by executive action, which then goes unchecked because Congress cannot respond — a dynamic the Brennan Center ties directly to filibuster gridlock.

The Back Door

51 votes

Budget reconciliation already bypasses the filibuster. Senate Republicans are now racing to pass one more filibuster-proof package before their majority expires.

That last card exposes the deepest hypocrisy of the current arrangement. Majority rule is already available in the Senate — for the right kind of bill. Tax cuts and spending cuts can move with 51 votes through reconciliation. Van Hollen’s agenda, as Roll Call reports, begins with restoring the Medicaid funding Republicans cut through last year’s reconciliation law. Cuts to Americans’ health care passed with a simple majority; restoring voting rights could not. That is not a neutral rule. It is a rule that systematically privileges dismantling government over building it.

III. Already Whittled Down — When It Suited Them

Defenders describe the filibuster as a sacred Senate tradition. Senate majorities treat it as a convenience. The so-called “nuclear option” — changing the chamber’s precedents by simple majority — has been used repeatedly to strip the 60-vote rule from whatever the majority of the moment found inconvenient.

Democrats went first. In November 2013, as Ballotpedia records, Majority Leader Harry Reid used the nuclear option after Republicans blocked three nominees to the D.C. Circuit, ending the filibuster for executive-branch and lower-court nominations. Republicans finished the job: in April 2017, Mitch McConnell extended the precedent to the Supreme Court to seat Neil Gorsuch. That single move made possible the confirmations that built the current 6–3 Court — the Court that went on to overturn Roe v. Wade and, as recently as this spring, to further limit the Voting Rights Act.

The GOP was not done. In September 2025, Senate Republicans voted 53–45 to set a new precedent letting the chamber confirm an unlimited number of sub-Cabinet nominees in a single en bloc vote, immediately advancing a package of 48. They borrowed the idea from a Democratic proposal by Sen. Amy Klobuchar — but, as Axios noted, Klobuchar’s version would have capped each batch at 10. Republicans removed the limit entirely.

So let us be precise about what remains. Republicans have used simple-majority rules changes to install Supreme Court justices and to mass-confirm Trump appointees. They use reconciliation to pass tax and spending cuts with 51 votes. The 60-vote wall still stands in front of exactly one category of business: ordinary legislation — the laws that a new majority would pass to answer the voters who elected it. The filibuster has not been preserved as a principle. It has been preserved as a selective barrier.

Get Involved Today

Contribute to our mission and turn your concerns into action.

IV. Who Pays: The Real Costs and the Claimed Benefits

A serious argument for abolition has to reckon with the serious case for keeping it, and there is one. Senate Majority Leader John Thune has called the rule “something that makes the Senate the Senate” and insists the 60-vote threshold has protected the country. In 2022 Joe Manchin warned that majority rule would only deepen the “dysfunction that is tearing this nation apart.” PolitiFact’s review of the debate lays out the strongest version: today’s majority will be tomorrow’s minority, and the rule gives every individual senator outsized leverage that many are loath to surrender.

There is also a timely version of that case on the left. Marcy Wheeler of emptywheel warns that making the filibuster a litmus test now could give lame-duck Republicans like Mike Lee the pretext to nuke it themselves before January — to ram through voting restrictions and other Trump priorities while they still can. That danger is real, and it is why how and when the rule ends matters as much as whether.

The Case Its Defenders Make

  • Forces some cross-party buy-in and slows sweeping swings in national policy.
  • Protects whichever party is in the minority — including Democrats, who used it against Trump's agenda in 2025–26.
  • Has blocked measures progressives oppose, such as the SAVE America Act's proof-of-citizenship voting rules.
  • Gives individual senators leverage to extract home-state concessions.

What It Actually Costs Americans

  • Popular bills — voting rights, abortion protections, gun safety — die without ever receiving a vote.
  • Lets senators representing a minority of Americans veto the majority on almost every question.
  • Rewards obstruction that carries no public cost under the "silent" filibuster.
  • Pushes real governing into executive orders and the courts, where voters have far less say.
  • Is already waived for tax cuts, spending cuts and judges — the protections are selective.

Weigh these honestly and the balance is not close. The protections the filibuster offers the minority are protections against voting. A party that cannot win an argument in public can still win by never letting the argument conclude. And the “stability” defenders prize is the stability of a system in which the voters’ clearest messages — like the one they delivered last week — are routinely converted into nothing.

Nor does the filibuster preserve debate. It destroys it. Real deliberation means bills come to the floor, amendments are offered, senators make their case and then vote. The modern Senate does almost none of this. Leaders negotiate privately over whether a bill can clear 60; if it cannot, it is never debated at all. Sen.-elect James Talarico of Texas put the point simply after his victory, calling the filibuster “a Jim Crow relic” that is driving gridlock. Ending it would not silence the minority. It would force the minority to make its case — and then lose, if the votes are not there.

V. Democratic Leadership’s Long Flinch

If the filibuster has survived, it is partly because Democratic leaders have never been willing to spend what it costs to kill it. The closest they came was January 2022. With the Freedom to Vote: John R. Lewis Act stalled, Majority Leader Schumer told colleagues the Senate “must evolve” and forced a vote on a narrow “talking filibuster” for that one bill. It failed 52–48, with Manchin and Sinema joining every Republican, while Mitch McConnell warned that changing the rule would “break the Senate.”

That loss was real, but it was not the whole story. For most of the years Democrats controlled the chamber, leadership treated the filibuster as a debate to be managed rather than a fight to be won. And this month, with an expanded majority in hand, Schumer has refused to say what he will do. At a post-election press conference, he twice declined to answer questions about abolishing it, offering instead that the first priority would be to “reduce people’s costs”. Lowering costs is the right goal. But a majority that cannot pass bills cannot lower anyone’s costs, and voters who just handed Democrats the Senate deserve to know whether their votes will be allowed to matter.

“…the filibuster is an antidemocratic — small ‘d’ — provision.”

— Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), Nov. 13, 2026, via The Hill

VI. The New Guard Moves the Fight to Center Stage

What has changed is who is in the room. On Thursday, Van Hollen made his challenge official, and on Friday in Denver he told reporters that the Senate should pass legislation with 51 votes — that a majority must be able to answer the call of the American people. He also ruled out a 2028 presidential run to make the race. He concedes he is the underdog in the secret-ballot leadership vote set for December 1, but says he has more than ten senators behind him, and Bernie Sanders and Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed quickly backed him.

The pressure is coming hardest from the incoming class. According to Democracy Now!, Senators-elect Peggy Flanagan, Troy Jackson, Abdul El-Sayed, Juliana Stratton and Adam Hamilton have all said they will not back Schumer. Stratton, who won in Illinois, said during her campaign that she would “absolutely support” abolishing the filibuster in order to protect reproductive freedom, voting rights and gun safety. El-Sayed made ending it a centerpiece of his Michigan campaign — so central that Trump himself seized on it in August to pressure Republicans.

The new caucus is not unanimous, and honesty requires saying so. A roundup compiled by Townhall reports that Iowa’s Josh Turek prefers restoring the “talking filibuster” over outright abolition, while North Carolina’s Roy Cooper has said he supports the rule “right now.” But the center of gravity has moved. A question that Democratic leaders spent years keeping off the table is now the defining question of the party’s leadership race — and it got there because voters sent a new generation of senators who refuse to treat procedure as destiny.

VII. Trump’s Filibuster: A Principle That Changes With the Majority

If anyone has demonstrated that the filibuster debate is about power, not principle, it is Donald Trump. His position has reversed whenever control of the Senate has changed hands — and he has said so out loud.

In 2017, with Republicans in charge, he wrote that the “Republican Senate must get rid of 60 vote NOW,” complaining it let a handful of Democrats control the country, as the Washington Examiner recalled. In March 2021, with Democrats in control, he reversed course, telling a podcast that ending the filibuster would be “catastrophic for the Republican Party” and floating a plan for Republicans to simply not show up so no vote could occur. Around the same period he praised Joe Manchin for “doing the right thing” by defending the rule.

Then Republicans regained the Senate, and the filibuster became an obstacle again. On October 30, 2025, during the government shutdown, he posted demands in all caps to initiate the “nuclear option”. Days later he urged Republicans to end it “not just for the shutdown, but for everything else.” Now, with his party about to lose the chamber, he is back at it, warning that failing to act before January would be “one of the greatest mistakes in the Political History of America” and tying it to the stalled SAVE America Act.

“Now I want to do it in order to take advantage of the Democrats.”

— President Donald Trump, Truth Social, Oct. 2025, via Raw Story

That sentence is the whole doctrine. Trump does not argue that majority rule is better for the country. He argues that whoever holds power should change the rules to entrench that power before the voters can take it away. He has predicted that if Republicans nuked the filibuster first, they would never lose another midterm or general election, and in August he warned that a Democratic Senate without it would lead to a Supreme Court of 23 justices and the last Republican president. The consistent principle is not about the Senate at all. It is that rules exist to serve him.

That is what this says about his leadership. A president who saw the filibuster as a matter of democratic legitimacy would hold one position regardless of who held the gavel. Trump has held every position, each timed to his advantage — and Senate Republicans, to their limited credit, have refused him. Thune says he lacks the votes. The lesson for Democrats is not that they should imitate Trump’s opportunism. It is that they should do the opposite: end the filibuster openly, as a matter of principle, through a majority voters just elected — and accept that the same rule will bind them when they lose.

Constitutional Analysis  ·  The Laws That Apply

The Constitution Expects Majority Rule. The Filibuster Is a Senate Choice, Not a Constitutional Command.

Art. I, § 5 — The Constitution provides that “each House may determine the Rules of its Proceedings” and that a majority of each chamber constitutes a quorum to do business. The filibuster is therefore a creature of Senate rules and precedent, fully within the Senate’s power to change — and, as 2013, 2017 and 2025 prove, changeable by simple majority through a ruling of the chair.

Enumerated supermajorities — The Framers knew how to require more than a majority, and did so explicitly: for ratifying treaties, overriding vetoes, convicting on impeachment, expelling members and proposing amendments. As the Brennan Center notes, that specificity signals that simple majority is the default for everything else, and some scholars argue a de facto 60-vote rule for all legislation sits uneasily with the constitutional design.

Rule XXII & the “nuclear option” — Formally amending Rule XXII requires a two-thirds vote to end debate on the change, which is why majorities use the precedent route: a point of order that cloture can be invoked by majority vote, sustained or overturned by 51 senators. That is precisely how Republicans reshaped nominations in September 2025.

Statutory carve-outs — Congress has already exempted certain measures from the filibuster by statute, most notably budget reconciliation under the Congressional Budget Act. The principle that the 60-vote rule can be set aside for some categories of legislation is not hypothetical; it is current law.

VIII. What You Can Do

Senate rules feel remote, but they are set by 100 people who answer to voters — and the next three weeks are the moment of maximum leverage. The Democratic caucus chooses its leader on December 1 by secret ballot, and the new majority will set its rules when the 120th Congress convenes in January. Here is what matters, in plain terms.

  1. Call your Democratic senators before December 1

    Ask one direct question: will they support a leader committed to restoring majority rule? Axios reports the leadership race gives grassroots activists nearly three weeks to make their views known before the secret ballot. The Capitol switchboard is (202) 224-3121.

  2. Demand a public rules vote in January — not a back-room deal

    A new Senate can adopt rule changes at the start of its session. Ask senators to commit to a recorded vote on eliminating or reforming the legislative filibuster in the opening weeks, so voters can see where each senator stands.

  3. Support the “talking filibuster” as the floor, not the ceiling

    If full abolition lacks 50 votes, the minimum acceptable reform is requiring obstructing senators to hold the floor and make their case — the approach Democrats tried in 2022 and that senators-elect like Josh Turek support. Obstruction should carry a public cost.

  4. Press for an immediate carve-out for voting rights

    The Senate already exempts reconciliation and nominations. A carve-out for the Freedom to Vote and John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement acts is a narrower step many senators have previously endorsed — and urgent after the Supreme Court’s latest Voting Rights Act decision.

  5. Watch the lame duck — and say so

    Republicans still control the Senate until January. Contact Republican senators, especially those leaving office, and urge them to reject any last-minute nuclear option to jam through the SAVE America Act or other Trump priorities. Ending the filibuster should be a decision of the majority the voters just elected, not a parting move by the one they rejected.

An Honest Assessment

Ending the filibuster in January will not, by itself, make Democratic bills law. President Trump keeps his veto through January 2029, and as local TV reporting notes, he has the final say on anything Congress passes; Democrats are far short of the two-thirds needed to override. What majority rule would do immediately is force recorded votes, put popular bills on the president’s desk, and make him own every veto in public. And it would ensure that the next unified government — of either party — can actually do what it was elected to do.

Editorial Conclusion

The filibuster was never in the Constitution. It began as a clerical accident, matured as the shield of slavery’s defenders and Jim Crow’s architects, and has curdled into a silent, cost-free veto that lets a minority stop the Senate from even debating the questions Americans send it to answer. Both parties have already carved it away when it blocked their judges and nominees. What remains protects only one thing: the minority’s power to make majority votes meaningless.

Donald Trump has shown us the cynical way to end it — as a weapon to entrench whoever holds power. Democrats must show the democratic way: openly, by recorded vote, at the start of a new Congress, with a majority the voters just chose, and with full acceptance that the same rule will bind them when they lose. Majority rule is not a partisan tactic. It is the promise of self-government. The new Senate must restore it.

Sources & References

  1. Brookings Institution — Sarah Binder, “The History of the Filibuster” (Senate Rules Committee testimony)
  2. National Constitution Center — “The Previous Question: The Filibuster’s Early Murky History”
  3. Brennan Center for Justice — “The Filibuster Explained”
  4. Brennan Center for Justice — “Rampant Filibuster Abuse Paralyzes Senate” (Curbing Filibuster Abuse, 2012)
  5. PolitiFact — “The History of the Filibuster as ‘Jim Crow Relic'”
  6. Augusta Free Press — “A History of the Filibuster, and Why It Should Be Tougher to Mount”
  7. Ballotpedia — “Filibuster and Reconciliation in the United States Congress”
  8. NPR — “Senate Pulls ‘Nuclear’ Trigger to Ease Gorsuch Confirmation”
  9. NBC News — “Senate Republicans Trigger ‘Nuclear Option’ to Speed Up Trump Nominees”
  10. Axios — “Senate GOP Invokes ‘Nuclear Option’ to Confirm Batches of Trump Nominees”
  11. PBS NewsHour / AP — “Schumer Announces Senate Vote on Filibuster Change” (Jan. 2022)
  12. PBS NewsHour / AP — “Push to Change Filibuster Rules Fails in the Senate”
  13. GV Wire / AP — “Voting Bill Collapses, Democrats Unable to Change Filibuster”
  14. The Center Square — “Democrats Divided on Filibuster’s Future If They Take Control of U.S. Senate”
  15. Nation of Change — Mitchell Zimmerman, “Blue Tsunami, Meet the Senate Filibuster”
  16. The Washington Times — “Senate GOP at Odds Over Last Filibuster-Proof Spending Bill Before Democrats Take Over”
  17. Las Vegas Sun / AP — “What’s the Filibuster and Why Does Trump Want to Get Rid of It?”
  18. PolitiFact — “How Do You Get Rid of the Filibuster? Trump Has Called for an End”
  19. PBS NewsHour / AP — “Trump Pushes Senate GOP on Filibuster ‘Nuclear Option’ to End the Shutdown”
  20. Anchorage Daily News / Washington Post — “A Long-Standing Senate Tradition Is Being Quietly Undermined”
  21. Washington Examiner — “Trump Pitches Nuking Filibuster to End Left-Wing Momentum”
  22. Washington Examiner — “Trump Warns Republicans Will ‘Never See Office Again’ if They Don’t ‘Terminate the Filibuster'”
  23. Yahoo News / Business Insider — “Trump Says It Would Be ‘Catastrophic for the Republican Party’ if the Senate Kills the Filibuster”
  24. AlterNet — “Trump Praises Joe Manchin for Defending the Filibuster”
  25. Raw Story — “‘We Will Never Lose’: Trump Reveals His Plan to Cement One-Party Rule”
  26. The Hill — “Trump Pressures GOP to Scrap Filibuster, Pointing to Abdul El-Sayed’s Comments”
  27. KTUL / The National News Desk — “Trump Reapplies Pressure on Senate Republicans Ahead of Democratic Takeover”
  28. Al Jazeera — “Democratic Party Wins US Senate in 2026 Midterm Elections”
  29. Fox News — “Schumer, Jeffries Sidestep Questions on Nuking Filibuster After Blue Wave”
  30. Just the News — “Democrats May Have Accidentally Triggered Republicans to Abolish Filibuster”
  31. NPR — “Chris Van Hollen Says He Will Challenge Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader”
  32. Roll Call — “Van Hollen Announces Bid for Majority Leader, but Schumer Says He Has the Votes”
  33. Axios — “Chris Van Hollen to Challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader”
  34. The Hill — “Van Hollen Says He Will Challenge Schumer for Majority Leader”
  35. The Hill — “Van Hollen Calls to Abolish Senate Filibuster, Rules Out 2028 White House Bid”
  36. Democracy Now! — “Incoming Freshman Senators Call for New Leadership to Replace Chuck Schumer”
  37. The Hill — “Stratton Would ‘Absolutely Support’ Abolishing Filibuster in Senate”
  38. Townhall — Roundup of incoming Democratic senators’ filibuster positions
  39. emptywheel — Marcy Wheeler, “Don’t Filibuster Faceplant!”

Related News

Scroll to Top